Statistics
- Total Options: 50
- Total Votes: 829
Current Rankings
- #1 Italian sausage (Elo: 1512, Matches: 45)
- #2 Pineapple (Elo: 1415, Matches: 42)
- #3 Spicy sausage (Elo: 1385, Matches: 35)
- #4 Sausage (Elo: 1375, Matches: 35)
- #5 Pepperoncini (Elo: 1370, Matches: 37)
- #6 Mushrooms (Elo: 1362, Matches: 32)
- #7 Meatballs (Elo: 1348, Matches: 39)
- #8 Pepperoni (Elo: 1331, Matches: 34)
- #9 Banana peppers (mild) (Elo: 1328, Matches: 30)
- #10 Grilled chicken (Elo: 1304, Matches: 41)
- #11 Green olives (Elo: 1299, Matches: 39)
- #12 Caramelized onions (Elo: 1287, Matches: 26)
- #13 Buffalo chicken (Elo: 1282, Matches: 28)
- #14 Banana peppers (Elo: 1276, Matches: 30)
- #15 Chicken (Elo: 1270, Matches: 26)
- #16 Green peppers (Elo: 1266, Matches: 35)
- #17 Onions (Elo: 1264, Matches: 23)
- #18 Philly steak (Elo: 1258, Matches: 38)
- #19 Ground beef (Elo: 1257, Matches: 25)
- #20 Bacon (Elo: 1253, Matches: 26)
- #21 Extra cheese (Elo: 1251, Matches: 27)
- #22 Garlic (Elo: 1249, Matches: 31)
- #23 BBQ chicken (Elo: 1234, Matches: 47)
- #24 Prosciutto (Elo: 1229, Matches: 36)
- #25 Ham (Elo: 1225, Matches: 28)
- #26 JalapeƱos (Elo: 1216, Matches: 28)
- #27 Salami (Elo: 1210, Matches: 33)
- #28 Roasted garlic (Elo: 1203, Matches: 42)
- #29 Red onions (Elo: 1198, Matches: 33)
- #30 Canadian bacon (Elo: 1197, Matches: 27)
- #31 Capicola (Elo: 1185, Matches: 35)
- #32 Steak (Elo: 1177, Matches: 35)
- #33 Pancetta (Elo: 1177, Matches: 27)
- #34 Hot honey (Elo: 1151, Matches: 43)
- #35 Pulled pork (Elo: 1143, Matches: 37)
- #36 Red chili flakes (Elo: 1137, Matches: 23)
- #37 Cherry peppers (Elo: 1132, Matches: 34)
- #38 Red peppers (Elo: 1118, Matches: 31)
- #39 Chorizo (Elo: 1093, Matches: 36)
- #40 Pesto (Elo: 1071, Matches: 18)
- #41 Serrano peppers (Elo: 1060, Matches: 28)
- #42 Roasted red peppers (Elo: 1058, Matches: 36)
- #43 Black olives (Elo: 1054, Matches: 31)
- #44 Habanero peppers (Elo: 1044, Matches: 33)
- #45 Lobster (Elo: 1038, Matches: 35)
- #46 Poblano peppers (Elo: 1006, Matches: 35)
- #47 Crab (Elo: 998, Matches: 32)
- #48 Shrimp (Elo: 977, Matches: 41)
- #49 Anchovies (Elo: 949, Matches: 36)
- #50 Clams (Elo: 887, Matches: 34)
Vote Now
Help rank these options by voting: Start Voting