The Ultimate Crumbl Cookie Flavor Ranking

Rank every flavor from the Crumbl library, including classics, limited-time specialties, and non-cookie desserts.

Statistics

Current Rankings

  1. #1 Buttermilk Pancake (Elo: 1389, Matches: 69)
  2. #2 Cookies & Cream Cocoa Mousse Cup (Elo: 1380, Matches: 54)
  3. #3 Waffle (Elo: 1379, Matches: 68)
  4. #4 Dubai Chocolate Cookie (Elo: 1377, Matches: 59)
  5. #5 Reese’s Cup ft. REESE'S (Elo: 1377, Matches: 63)
  6. #6 Blueberry Muffin (Elo: 1369, Matches: 49)
  7. #7 Chocolate Crumb ft. OREO (Elo: 1357, Matches: 60)
  8. #8 Caramel Shortbread Featuring Twix (Elo: 1355, Matches: 45)
  9. #9 Biscoff Lava ft. BISCOFF (Elo: 1347, Matches: 63)
  10. #10 Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk (Elo: 1342, Matches: 59)
  11. #11 Cinnamon Twist (Elo: 1341, Matches: 30)
  12. #12 Cookie Dough (Elo: 1336, Matches: 48)
  13. #13 Cinnamon Roll (Elo: 1333, Matches: 39)
  14. #14 Cinnamon Square (Elo: 1332, Matches: 55)
  15. #15 Cookie Butter Lava (Elo: 1324, Matches: 59)
  16. #16 Ultimate Peanut Butter (Elo: 1322, Matches: 86)
  17. #17 Galaxy Brownie (Elo: 1321, Matches: 72)
  18. #18 Biscoff Ice Cream ft. BISCOFF (Elo: 1320, Matches: 65)
  19. #19 Raspberry Cheesecake (Elo: 1314, Matches: 74)
  20. #20 Chocolate Peanut Butter with Oreo (Elo: 1304, Matches: 46)
  21. #21 Lemon Bar (Elo: 1304, Matches: 62)
  22. #22 Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Muffin (Elo: 1302, Matches: 50)
  23. #23 Cookies & Cream (Elo: 1302, Matches: 30)
  24. #24 Chocolate Cookies and Cream (Elo: 1301, Matches: 39)
  25. #25 Cookie Butter Ice Cream (Elo: 1301, Matches: 46)
  26. #26 Celebration Cake (Elo: 1300, Matches: 63)
  27. #27 Graham Cracker with Teddy Grahams (Elo: 1299, Matches: 36)
  28. #28 Sea Salt Toffee (Elo: 1298, Matches: 72)
  29. #29 Honey Bun (Elo: 1297, Matches: 49)
  30. #30 Double Fudge Brownie Cookie (Elo: 1293, Matches: 24)
  31. #31 Raspberry Butter Cake (Elo: 1287, Matches: 43)
  32. #32 Toffee Sea Salt (Elo: 1286, Matches: 58)
  33. #33 Vanilla Sugar (Elo: 1283, Matches: 49)
  34. #34 Birthday Cake (Valentine) (Elo: 1282, Matches: 57)
  35. #35 Blueberry Muffin Cookie (Elo: 1282, Matches: 34)
  36. #36 Muddy Buddy (Elo: 1281, Matches: 40)
  37. #37 Blueberry Pancake Cookie (Elo: 1280, Matches: 27)
  38. #38 Birthday Cake Featuring Oreo (Elo: 1280, Matches: 41)
  39. #39 Chocolate Mallow Cupcake (Elo: 1277, Matches: 43)
  40. #40 Mallow Sandwich ft. OREO (Elo: 1275, Matches: 70)
  41. #41 Hazelnut Churro (Elo: 1272, Matches: 48)
  42. #42 Nilla Bean Cupcake (Elo: 1272, Matches: 75)
  43. #43 Chocolate Crumb Cake with Oreo (Elo: 1272, Matches: 36)
  44. #44 Dubai Chocolate Brownie (Elo: 1270, Matches: 59)
  45. #45 S'mores (Elo: 1270, Matches: 67)
  46. #46 Classic Pink Sugar (Elo: 1270, Matches: 55)
  47. #47 Chocolate Cupcake (Elo: 1270, Matches: 43)
  48. #48 Cinnamon Toast Crunch (Elo: 1269, Matches: 40)
  49. #49 Caramel Apple (Elo: 1266, Matches: 92)
  50. #50 Butterfinger (Elo: 1266, Matches: 42)
  51. #51 Hazelnut Sea Salt ft. NUTELLA (Elo: 1264, Matches: 67)
  52. #52 Cinnamon Pretzel (Elo: 1264, Matches: 30)
  53. #53 Chocolate Cake with Heath (Elo: 1263, Matches: 34)
  54. #54 Cookies & Cream Milkshake (Elo: 1261, Matches: 43)
  55. #55 Reese’s Pieces ft. REESE'S (Elo: 1261, Matches: 73)
  56. #56 Snickerdoodle (Elo: 1260, Matches: 67)
  57. #57 Brownie Sundae (Elo: 1259, Matches: 54)
  58. #58 POP-TARTS® Cookie (Elo: 1259, Matches: 45)
  59. #59 Oreo (Elo: 1256, Matches: 35)
  60. #60 Cake Batter (Elo: 1256, Matches: 33)
  61. #61 Holiday Red Velvet Sandwich Cookie (Elo: 1255, Matches: 30)
  62. #62 Cake Batter Blondie (Elo: 1254, Matches: 41)
  63. #63 Funfetti (Elo: 1254, Matches: 59)
  64. #64 Chocolate Strawberry Cheesecake (Elo: 1254, Matches: 29)
  65. #65 Cornbread (Elo: 1254, Matches: 58)
  66. #66 Chocolate Featuring Oreo (Elo: 1253, Matches: 43)
  67. #67 Triple Berry Shortcake (Elo: 1253, Matches: 89)
  68. #68 Strawberries N’ Cream (Elo: 1253, Matches: 38)
  69. #69 Hazelnut Mudslide with Nutella (Elo: 1252, Matches: 46)
  70. #70 French Toast (Elo: 1252, Matches: 60)
  71. #71 German Chocolate Cake (Elo: 1252, Matches: 42)
  72. #72 Pineapple Upside Down Cake (Elo: 1251, Matches: 42)
  73. #73 Cinnamon Swirl (Elo: 1251, Matches: 37)
  74. #74 Pineapple Dole Whip (Elo: 1248, Matches: 104)
  75. #75 Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip (Elo: 1247, Matches: 36)
  76. #76 Gingersnap (Elo: 1245, Matches: 40)
  77. #77 Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie (Elo: 1245, Matches: 34)
  78. #78 Apple Pie (Elo: 1243, Matches: 65)
  79. #79 Dirt Cake Featuring OTTO (Elo: 1243, Matches: 31)
  80. #80 Pumpkin Sheet Cake Cookie (Elo: 1243, Matches: 35)
  81. #81 Halloween Confetti Milksake Cookie (Elo: 1240, Matches: 35)
  82. #82 Buckeye Brownie (Elo: 1240, Matches: 39)
  83. #83 Pink Sugar Cookie Cake (Elo: 1238, Matches: 55)
  84. #84 Lucky Charms (Elo: 1238, Matches: 75)
  85. #85 Dulce de Leche (Elo: 1234, Matches: 53)
  86. #86 Berries & Cream (Elo: 1234, Matches: 41)
  87. #87 Peanut Butter Jamwich (Elo: 1233, Matches: 44)
  88. #88 Chocolate Peanut Butter Featuring Oreo (Elo: 1232, Matches: 32)
  89. #89 Chocolate Covered Strawberry (Elo: 1229, Matches: 65)
  90. #90 Chocolate Toffee Cake (Elo: 1228, Matches: 47)
  91. #91 Gingerbread Cake (Elo: 1228, Matches: 60)
  92. #92 Blueberry Crumb Cake (Elo: 1228, Matches: 38)
  93. #93 Cookies & Cream Tres Leches Cake (Elo: 1227, Matches: 40)
  94. #94 Brownie Batter Cookie (Elo: 1226, Matches: 41)
  95. #95 Classic Fudge Brownie (Elo: 1226, Matches: 43)
  96. #96 Brown Sugar Cinnamon ft. POP-TARTS (Elo: 1225, Matches: 43)
  97. #97 The Cookie That Stole Christmas (Elo: 1225, Matches: 44)
  98. #98 Boston Cream Pie (Elo: 1225, Matches: 44)
  99. #99 Circus Animal (Elo: 1225, Matches: 39)
  100. #100 Chocolate Crunch (Elo: 1224, Matches: 30)
  101. #101 Chocolate with York Peppermint (Elo: 1224, Matches: 28)
  102. #102 Peanut Butter Cup Skillet Cookie (with Reese’s) (Elo: 1224, Matches: 43)
  103. #103 Blueberry Cheesecake (Elo: 1223, Matches: 35)
  104. #104 Mango Frozen Yogurt (Elo: 1222, Matches: 67)
  105. #105 Cinnamon Fry Bread (Elo: 1222, Matches: 36)
  106. #106 Strawberry Milk (Elo: 1221, Matches: 28)
  107. #107 Monster ft. M&Ms (Elo: 1220, Matches: 68)
  108. #108 Peanut Butter & Jelly (Elo: 1217, Matches: 41)
  109. #109 Cowboy Cookie (Elo: 1217, Matches: 40)
  110. #110 Blue Monster ft. Chips Ahoy! (Elo: 1216, Matches: 82)
  111. #111 Oatmeal Butterscotch (Elo: 1216, Matches: 33)
  112. #112 Key Lime Pie (Elo: 1216, Matches: 66)
  113. #113 Salted Caramel Cheesecake (Elo: 1215, Matches: 28)
  114. #114 Peanut Butter Bar (Elo: 1214, Matches: 39)
  115. #115 Dirt Cake (Elo: 1214, Matches: 75)
  116. #116 New York Cheesecake (Elo: 1214, Matches: 68)
  117. #117 Almond Joy (Elo: 1214, Matches: 35)
  118. #118 Kentucky Butter Cake (Elo: 1214, Matches: 77)
  119. #119 Chocolate with Reese’s Puffs (Elo: 1212, Matches: 40)
  120. #120 Cookie Butter White Chip (Elo: 1209, Matches: 36)
  121. #121 Cookie Dough Crunch Ice Cream (Elo: 1209, Matches: 28)
  122. #122 Cookie Cup (Elo: 1208, Matches: 28)
  123. #123 Strawberry Shortcake (Elo: 1208, Matches: 78)
  124. #124 Cereal Milk ft. Fruity Pebbles (Elo: 1205, Matches: 48)
  125. #125 Strawberry Cake (Elo: 1203, Matches: 38)
  126. #126 Pink Doughnut (Elo: 1203, Matches: 33)
  127. #127 Lemon Glaze (Elo: 1203, Matches: 45)
  128. #128 Double Fudge Sandwich (Elo: 1203, Matches: 76)
  129. #129 Vanilla Crumb Cake ft. Golden OREO (Elo: 1203, Matches: 73)
  130. #130 Maple Glaze (Elo: 1203, Matches: 40)
  131. #131 Caramel Cake (Elo: 1202, Matches: 30)
  132. #132 Strawberry Pretzel Pie (Elo: 1202, Matches: 43)
  133. #133 Sugar with Sour Patch Kids (Elo: 1200, Matches: 32)
  134. #134 Pink Velvet Cake (Elo: 1200, Matches: 61)
  135. #135 Kitchen Sink (Elo: 1199, Matches: 64)
  136. #136 Texas Sheet Cake (Elo: 1197, Matches: 45)
  137. #137 Chocolate Sprinkle (Elo: 1197, Matches: 44)
  138. #138 Peanut Butter Brownie (Elo: 1197, Matches: 47)
  139. #139 Churro (Elo: 1195, Matches: 61)
  140. #140 Peanut Butter with Snickers (Elo: 1194, Matches: 29)
  141. #141 Pumpkin Pie (Elo: 1194, Matches: 57)
  142. #142 Candy Cane Brownie Cookie (Elo: 1194, Matches: 37)
  143. #143 Pineapple Whip (Elo: 1193, Matches: 27)
  144. #144 Tres Leches Cake (Elo: 1191, Matches: 57)
  145. #145 Brookie Pie (Elo: 1191, Matches: 46)
  146. #146 Lemon Cheesecake (Elo: 1187, Matches: 45)
  147. #147 Strawberry Ice Cream (Elo: 1185, Matches: 33)
  148. #148 Passion Fruit (Elo: 1185, Matches: 19)
  149. #149 Eggnog Tres Leches Cake (Elo: 1185, Matches: 34)
  150. #150 Pumpkin Cheesecake Cookie (Elo: 1183, Matches: 38)
  151. #151 Peanut Butter Brittle (Elo: 1183, Matches: 34)
  152. #152 Minion Confetti (Elo: 1183, Matches: 43)
  153. #153 Butterscotch Chip (Elo: 1182, Matches: 43)
  154. #154 Triple Berry Cobbler (Elo: 1182, Matches: 38)
  155. #155 Maple Cinnamon Roll (Elo: 1182, Matches: 39)
  156. #156 Strawberry Crumb Cake (Elo: 1182, Matches: 37)
  157. #157 Fried Ice Cream (Elo: 1182, Matches: 44)
  158. #158 Lemon Blackberry (Elo: 1181, Matches: 46)
  159. #159 Vanilla Bean (Elo: 1181, Matches: 40)
  160. #160 Coconut Layer Cake Cookie (Elo: 1181, Matches: 36)
  161. #161 Confetti Cake (Elo: 1181, Matches: 37)
  162. #162 Red Velvet Cupcake (Elo: 1180, Matches: 61)
  163. #163 Turtle (Elo: 1177, Matches: 66)
  164. #164 Frosted Strawberry Pop-Tarts (Elo: 1176, Matches: 37)
  165. #165 Lemon Chiffon (Elo: 1176, Matches: 55)
  166. #166 Peach Sugar with Peachie Os (Elo: 1174, Matches: 28)
  167. #167 Almond Coconut Fudge (Elo: 1169, Matches: 35)
  168. #168 Chocolate Malt Featuring Tootsie Roll (Elo: 1169, Matches: 21)
  169. #169 Lemon Poppy Seed (Elo: 1169, Matches: 73)
  170. #170 Pumpkin Oreo Cheesecake (Elo: 1168, Matches: 43)
  171. #171 Chocolate Chip Cookie Thins (Elo: 1168, Matches: 24)
  172. #172 Raspberry Lemonade (Elo: 1167, Matches: 31)
  173. #173 Peanut Butter Cookies & Cream (Elo: 1167, Matches: 19)
  174. #174 Chocolate Covered Strawberry (Elo: 1165, Matches: 36)
  175. #175 Pumpkin Cake (Elo: 1165, Matches: 38)
  176. #176 Peanut Butter Creme featuring Nutter Butter (Elo: 1164, Matches: 30)
  177. #177 Pumpkin Roll (Elo: 1163, Matches: 33)
  178. #178 Monster (Elo: 1160, Matches: 46)
  179. #179 Berry Crunch (Elo: 1160, Matches: 36)
  180. #180 Andes Mint (Elo: 1159, Matches: 47)
  181. #181 Cranberry White Chip with Ocean Spray (Elo: 1158, Matches: 29)
  182. #182 Mile-High Lemon Pie Cookie (Elo: 1157, Matches: 29)
  183. #183 Caramel Coconut Fudge / Chilled Samoa (Elo: 1157, Matches: 38)
  184. #184 Walnut Brownie Fudge (Elo: 1155, Matches: 32)
  185. #185 Aggie Blue Mint (Elo: 1155, Matches: 45)
  186. #186 Fruit Pizza (Elo: 1155, Matches: 55)
  187. #187 Cotton Candy (Elo: 1152, Matches: 29)
  188. #188 Coconut Lime (Elo: 1152, Matches: 26)
  189. #189 Neapolitan (Elo: 1151, Matches: 55)
  190. #190 Coconut Cake (Elo: 1151, Matches: 46)
  191. #191 Mint Brownie (Elo: 1151, Matches: 47)
  192. #192 Shark Sugar (Elo: 1147, Matches: 37)
  193. #193 Mom’s Recipe (Elo: 1147, Matches: 26)
  194. #194 Hot Cocoa (Elo: 1146, Matches: 61)
  195. #195 Dark Dream (Elo: 1145, Matches: 55)
  196. #196 Lemonade (Elo: 1144, Matches: 23)
  197. #197 Mint Chip Ice Cream Cookie (Elo: 1143, Matches: 37)
  198. #198 Pumpkin Cream Pie (Elo: 1142, Matches: 35)
  199. #199 Strawberry Cake Cookie (Elo: 1141, Matches: 39)
  200. #200 Lemon Crinkle (Elo: 1139, Matches: 48)
  201. #201 French Silk Pie (Elo: 1138, Matches: 38)
  202. #202 Candy Corn (Elo: 1137, Matches: 31)
  203. #203 Maple Bacon (Elo: 1137, Matches: 36)
  204. #204 Maple Bacon Sugar (Elo: 1135, Matches: 33)
  205. #205 Original with Kit Kat (Elo: 1135, Matches: 30)
  206. #206 Milk Chocolate Chip (Elo: 1135, Matches: 68)
  207. #207 Banana Pudding (Elo: 1135, Matches: 75)
  208. #208 Chocolate Orange Truffle (Elo: 1134, Matches: 33)
  209. #209 Molten Lava (Elo: 1132, Matches: 70)
  210. #210 Oatmeal Raisin (Elo: 1131, Matches: 63)
  211. #211 Walnut Chocolate Chip Cookie (Elo: 1130, Matches: 31)
  212. #212 Pina Colada (Elo: 1130, Matches: 42)
  213. #213 Classic Krispy Bar (Elo: 1126, Matches: 48)
  214. #214 Pumpkin Square Cookie (Elo: 1126, Matches: 22)
  215. #215 Midnight Mint (Elo: 1125, Matches: 59)
  216. #216 Frozen Hot Chocolate (Elo: 1124, Matches: 59)
  217. #217 Blue Raspberry with ICEE (Elo: 1121, Matches: 35)
  218. #218 Carrot Cake (Elo: 1117, Matches: 62)
  219. #219 Peanut Butter Blossom (Elo: 1112, Matches: 38)
  220. #220 Almond Sand Dollar (Elo: 1112, Matches: 29)
  221. #221 Peppermint Bark (Elo: 1111, Matches: 74)
  222. #222 Coconut Cream (Elo: 1110, Matches: 40)
  223. #223 Banana Bread Cookie (Elo: 1109, Matches: 41)
  224. #224 Sugar – Gold Coin (Elo: 1108, Matches: 30)
  225. #225 Rocky Road (Elo: 1107, Matches: 74)
  226. #226 Apple Cider Muffin (Elo: 1106, Matches: 71)
  227. #227 Chocolate Tart Cookie (Elo: 1104, Matches: 59)
  228. #228 Chocolate Caramel (Elo: 1103, Matches: 36)
  229. #229 Coconut White Chip (Elo: 1102, Matches: 35)
  230. #230 Cornflake Marshmallow (Elo: 1102, Matches: 29)
  231. #231 Pumpkin Chocolate Chip (Elo: 1095, Matches: 40)
  232. #232 Iced Oatmeal (Elo: 1094, Matches: 61)
  233. #233 Oatmeal Chocolate Chip (Elo: 1094, Matches: 37)
  234. #234 Peaches N’ Cream (Elo: 1089, Matches: 44)
  235. #235 Orange Milkshake (Elo: 1088, Matches: 40)
  236. #236 Watermelon (Elo: 1088, Matches: 50)
  237. #237 Italian Rainbow Cake (Elo: 1087, Matches: 91)
  238. #238 Ube Stuffed Cheesecake (Elo: 1084, Matches: 76)
  239. #239 Chocolate Potato Chip (Elo: 1077, Matches: 44)
  240. #240 Sherbet (Elo: 1071, Matches: 28)
  241. #241 Caramel Pumpkin (Elo: 1069, Matches: 43)
  242. #242 Peach Cobbler (Elo: 1066, Matches: 55)
  243. #243 Macadamia Nut (Elo: 1063, Matches: 56)
  244. #244 Peanut Butter Banana (Elo: 1062, Matches: 35)
  245. #245 Limeade (Elo: 1057, Matches: 76)
  246. #246 Orange Creamsicle (Elo: 1055, Matches: 84)
  247. #247 Eggnog (Elo: 1054, Matches: 41)
  248. #248 Caramel Popcorn (Elo: 1044, Matches: 50)
  249. #249 Mooncake (Elo: 1037, Matches: 36)
  250. #250 Banana Cream Pie (Elo: 1027, Matches: 78)
  251. #251 Everything Bagel (Elo: 1017, Matches: 72)
  252. #252 Hawaiian Rainbow Cake (Elo: 1009, Matches: 58)
  253. #253 Orange Roll (Elo: 1003, Matches: 51)
  254. #254 Bubble Gum (Elo: 1000, Matches: 34)
  255. #255 Almost Everything Bagel (Elo: 908, Matches: 62)

Vote Now

Help rank these options by voting: Start Voting